Occupy Jamaica, Part 2: The lay of the reef

 Discovery Bay, Jamaica.  8:23 PM.  End of my second full (long) day since arriving Friday afternoon. Kristin, James, and Solomon had arrived Tuesday — three days ahead of me – and made good progress reconnoitering and sampling at the sites we’d worked in 2008. By this evening we had collected and processed over 100 samples of sponges and dead coral rubble, and scored several colonies of our primary quarry: the social shrimp Synalpheus regalis and Synalpheus duffyi.

The weather is fairly predictable here: Calm at daybreak, with the breeze stiffening as the atmosphere warms through the morning. White-capped seas are typical in the afternoon. Hence we arrived the dock at 0700, and eventually got all parties on board to depart.

Our first stop is the reef at Rio Bueno, at the edge of the reef platform a bit west of Discovery Bay on the north shore of the island. A fresh and promising day, with blue skies and excellent visibility on the bottom, though the chop is already up by mid-morning when we go under. From our vantage on the water the uplifted Pleistocene reefs of the island are clearly visible as a long wall of limestone cliffs parallel to shore and clothed with tropical forest. We submerge and head for the drop-off, scanning constantly for the partially consolidated reef rubble that signals the presence of cryptic sponges and the shrimps that call them home.

Collecting reef rubble samples for shrimp

I am pleasantly surprised by the high coral cover at Rio Bueno. For years Jamaica has served as a poster child for a global trend in decaying coral reef ecosystems – overfished and with once luxurious coral gardens long gone, and replaced by algae. There is no question that Discovery Bay has been hard hit – on my last trip here in 2008 I was stunned by the boneyard aspect of the forereef. And the elkhorn and staghorn corals that dominated shallow reefs of Jamaica and most of the Caribbean in the 1970s – and indeed for at least the past few thousand years — are hardly to be seen. The reef has shifted to a very different composition, even where coral cover is high. And the new dominants appear vigorous . . .

High coral cover at Rio Bueno

As John has noted here before, there are signs of hope. We saw many – albeit scattered and small – colonies of the once mighty elkhorn (Acropora palmata) and some staghorn (A. cervicornis) colonies as well. A promising day indeed.

Signs of hope: Elkorn coral regaining a toehold

Fish are another story entirely. There are essentially none, at least nothing much larger than a damselfish. During our dives at Dairy Bull reef on the second day we can see why. A line of fish traps, each the size of a small car, extending most of the way along a sand groove in the reef. It’s hard to imagine what is caught in these things or how anyone can make a living working them. I looked up close at one and saw a single jack, maybe a pound and a half, and a trumpet fish. While we were down a boat came by to service them. Meanwhile out on the reef, small schools of various wrasses occasionally pass by. That’s it.

Empty fish traps

Two dives today and we’re back by 0930. We spend the rest of the morning in the wet lab, picking through coral rock and sponge samples, searching for the tiny shrimp that have diversified explosively to occupy nearly every little nook and cranny in the reef. It is wet, sweaty painstaking work (a hard point to get across to our friends back in the frozen USA) but the tedium is broken up by moments of discovery – a little octopus slithers out of a hole in the rock and inks Kristin, a probable new species of shrimp turns up, a bizarre flatworm uncoils from between coral branches. We spend the rest of the afternoon identifying the shrimp specimens and processing them for study and DNA extraction.

Back in the lab, pickin' shrimp

After four days of this schedule, starting at 0630 and finishing often near or after midnight, we at last finish before dark. We wash the tools, pack everything up, lock the lab, and head back to sample the Jamaican rum.

Tomorrow’s another day . . .


Posted

in

by

Comments

7 responses to “Occupy Jamaica, Part 2: The lay of the reef”

  1. Abel

    oh! I remember that view (2nd picture) of you guys collecting rubble (“shrimp condos”) ….the only thing missing is the big Goliath grouper smelling the bag……Really!!! (5th picture), no wonder the average fish size in Jamaica is 5cm!

  2. I cannot believe that picture of all the fish traps!!! Ive never seen anything like that. Ive dove on those reefs hundreds of times and never saw such a high density of traps.

    And what socioeconomic dynamics accounts for that? The intensity of fishing increases once the harvested species are entirely depleted?

    1. Emmett Duffy

      Go figure — I also could not believe it. What is the business model — hundreds of dollars in overhead for a single fish caught!

      1. But isn’t that exactly the business model we see elsewhere (such as New England). As fish catch declines heap on more investment in gear to chase the last fish. Also in terrestrial, higher and higher investment in getting every last ______. It seems (from 1500 miles away and through the lens of a web blog) that this may be the same thing a desperate attempt to hold onto a business/model that is unsustainable, doubling down with a frame of mind that there is nothing left to lose. It’s not really rational – more emotional than anything else?

        1. Emmett Duffy

          I think you’ve hit on an important — and general — point, Eric. Once a community or an individual has developed a way of life that is heavily invested in doing something in a certain way, it becomes difficult to see the signs that it’s failing, sometimes spectacularly.

  3. Emmett, how did the cervicornis look at Dairy Bull?

    1. Emmett Duffy

      Not a lot of cervicornis, certainly not like the picture you posted from 2003. But we did see colonies here and there so it is certainly present. Having seen virtually no cervicornis for a decade or more in the places I’ve been in Caribbean I actually considered that a hopeful sign.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *